2. "Cold and dampness does NOT cause viruses or colds.
Sorry. Scientifically there's negative evidence for this (though my mother
has made that claim for years, too). What most likely happens is that
there are molds present on whatever object is damp and the mold/mildew reduces
your immunity (or causes an allergic reaction very similar to a cold or the
flu). My first allergist speculated heavily that I'd never had a real cold
because I have such a wide range of allergies. Since you already know that
you've had mold exposures and are highly sensitive to molds, chances are really
good just a hint of mold or mildew on the damp dress caused a severe
reaction. Here's an interesting tidbit as well. People with CFS/fibro
don't have normal allergic reactions. I recently had both skin and RAST
testing for my allergies (which were far more than this present ENT doctor had
ever seen in one person). RAST testing just looks for IgE elevations to
specific allergens, which is the NORMAL response. I had only ONE item
elevate IgE - MOLD. Most likely the other allergens are provoking either
IgG1 or Th cells. Just remember, the watch word with us is
ABERRANT reactions to the world."
7. "In response to your question about getting cold and having that
trigger colds and viruses. I don't experience that. In fact-- aside
from the FMS (possibly Lyme) symptoms, I never rarely if ever get a flu bug,
virus or cold. I've read on the CFS/FMS message board on immunesupport.com
similar feedback. That many with CFS/FMS never get "normal"
illnesses. Perhaps my immune system is in overdrive
- I'm not sure."
9. "I am very prone to bronchitis and asthma. When I get
chilled or fail to keep warm, I often find myself coming down
with a cold, sore throat, etc., shortly afterward."
11. "A chill alone
cannot cause illness, but if you have the bug in your system, it might lower
resistance. A
good place to check for info is Medline. I always look at the studies, not the
info for laypersons. Just use the
search engine, maybe type chill and illness."
14. "OH MY GOSH YES! I didn’t even realize that this might
be it! The last few days in MN it has been c-c-c-c-cold! Between -7
and +15 deg and I have had a sore throat every day, for no apparent
reason. I have not been around anyone sick, my son has not had a
sore throat, and no one around me has had one. But it’s been so bad it
felt like it was on fire the last couple days. I had no idea how I could
have gotten it—until now that is. It makes perfect sense, because
I too was a “sickly” child living in the cold damp north
MN."
15. "I think these people saying it can not cause a cold mean that
you must already have been exposed to a virus it will not just pop up if you are
cold. Because I have read how when the body's temp is lowered it can
take up to hours for it to return to normal, depending on the situation.
This overworks the body - another name - stress - and stress lowers resistance
so in those of us who are already very weakened it is a
nightmare. Also, when I do my ice therapy per my chiro it is for no more
than 15 minutes and I get under plenty of covers, with socks, and make sure the
room is at a good temp (76-78). The ice does help the swelling from
inflammation but I must stay warm. Finally when in doubt, I follow old
fashioned advice. Many of these people lived full lives without
anitbiotics, etc. So, they always bundled up - therefore,
I consider it good advice."
16. "There have been studies that indicate no relationship, but other
studies have suggested that there is a relationship between
getting cold and damp and then catching a cold/virus. The jury is still
out. The body does get stressed in the damp cold and
therefore less resisitant to illness. If you wear damp clothing,
the blood vessels in the nose get constricted, which keeps white cells out of
the area and could increase chance of infection. So, although the cold
itself is not the culprit, the cold and damp might allow the virus to get ahold
of you. I get sick whenever I drink even just a little alcohol. Just
a glass of wine is all it takes. The alcohol apparently stresses
my body and always results in a virus. I avoid alcohol as a
result."
17. "I'm sure you've found and read
about the numerous scientific studies done that show there's no
link between catching cold viruses and being in cool-damp
locations. One I heard about on TV showed the control group in
warm-dry conditions had the same "catch" rate when all were exposed as the
cool-damp group. You mentioned
people who have difficulty maintaining body temp; I'm one such person,
especially after my radiation therapy for a perotid tumor. Along with my
fibro, I've developed secondary Reynauds Phenomenon. It's
main symptom is fingers & toes (and sometimes nose & ears) losing
circulation and turning white mainly when expose to cool temperatures which
causes inflamation of the smallest capillaries shutting off circulation.
It's hell to have this in Nebraska in the winter or even the fall or
spring. It came on gradually along with my fibro and it cycles in
severeness. It's a common secondary effect found in Fibro, RA, MS and
other immune-ralated illnesses. My
radiation therapy may've caused the Reynaud's to worsen, but it may've been
going that way anyhow. It just seemed to make a quantum jump during the
end of the therapy. One day my body temp dropped to 96.0 (threshold of
hypothermia) at a McDonalds during lunch and four fingers went white on
me--2 on each hand. It was a chilly McDonalds for sure. So given my temperature issues, you're theory would
mean that I should be getting colds a lot more often. It has not been the
case. In fact, I've had fewer colds, but that is purely anecdotal.
That's the problem with anecdotal
evidence; it's easy to make connections when none exist."
18. "Yes, yes,
yes, always. I live in Arizona, which is very dry, as we know, but when
it rains here and when it's "colder", my throat is sore usually all
these months. In fact, we just recently experienced a rain and a cool down (for
the Phoenix metro area), and my throat has been so sore, I've been getting the
typical hoarseness that I've seen as a symptom I think of M.E. although it might
also be one of fibro too. Since I have symptoms of both as well as CFS (or
CFIDS, whatever you want to call it), it's hard to tell which symptom is from
what. Like the sore throat could be from fibro or CFS, but I think the
hoarseness and even loss of ability to speak at all is M.E. But my throat has
been raw, and I went out and got my usual 100 sore throat pain drops that gets
me through the "winter" here. One winter, I also had such bad shortness of
breath and chondroitis that I couldn't stand for anything tight against my
chest, couldn't wear a bra or tight clothing and used Vicks Vapor Rub every
winter. I have what you have too, except at first my fever was 101 and
then it was 98.7 and then up to 100 and then down and up for the past week or
two. I'm sure I also have a cold with this, because my head feels stuffed with
cotton, but I used something for immune support for Walgreens every three or
four hours last week for three days in a row and at least I got rid of "hearing"
water in my head whenever I moved my head. Plus, here's what I learned
in nursing school, and to tell you the truth your husband is right in
one sense. Colds/sore throats are not caused by getting chilled or
damp. Nothing is. However, when one becomes chilled or damp, it's a
shock to the system and the stress response kicks in. When the body's entire
homeostasis is upset in this way, if you're already not 100 percent healthy and
normal, you can catch just about everything going around. And with fibro, we're
already compromised, although it's not an autoimmune disorder, they say, but
having pain and fatigue and never knowing what you can do and when is extremely
stressful. And fighting this, we already probably have stress and thus
lowered immunity. So breathe air that's filled with viruses or even touch your
husband's hand, which he may not have washed when he last shook hands with
someone, and he has no problems with his health, so his body is equipped to
fight infections, whereas yours is not, and there you go, you're sick. I
knew there was a reason I caught everything, and when I got all these tests done
at the Fibro & Fatigue Centers, I was shocked to see that my immunity was
severely compromised: IgG, IgM, IgA were all way below normal."
19. "I have to
be very careful of damp and windy days. Actually whenever the weather
changes. From nice to humid, from nice to rain, from cold to very cold.
High winds always do my sinuses in. I have fought multiple yearly
colds/viruses since I was a little kid. I was probably the first generation who
was prescribed penicilliin/antibiotics continually. My parents
who had never visited doctors themselves while growing up took me whenever
I had "any" symptoms. I was always on antibiotics which I
feel has a lot to do with my health issues now. This is what
usually works for me now--90% of the time. If I immediately take
supplements at the FIRST FEEL of any kind of nose/throat/chest
symptoms, I can nip it before it takes over. Even if I am not sure--is it
allergy or ?? I take it. I have had huge success with the following routine for
the past 5 years. Even when my immune system was very low from breast cancer
treatments this kept my symptoms from worsening. I take Cold-Eeze lozenges
(which are awful) every 2 hrs, then the following 2xday: Echinacea with
goldenseal, Grapefruit seed-125mg, Initial Defense by Kan and a prescribed
decongestant Respaire-120. My symptoms usually are gone by the third day without
my getting worse. I have to take these asap. I have had symptoms come up when I
have not been home and have stopped what I was doing to go home and get them. If
I am too far and 4/6 hrs go by it is usually too late and I am down. However, I
take the above as soon as I can and often(not always) symptoms may last only a
week. I have been known to have a cold/virus for 2-4 weeks in the past.
This is what helps for me. Everyone is different and if you have high blood
pressure or other med conditions I am not sure what can or cannot be
taken."
20. "I too, have always been told by doctors
that you can't get sick from being under a ceiling fan, damp or cold air, or by
wearing damp clothing etc. I do know that just like you, the humid
weather in Florida affects me worse than almost
anything else. When we do have those rare days of cooler weather
with low humidity..... I feel SO much better. The difference
is remarkable! I have seriously considered moving to a drier climate. The
other thing that greatly impacts my condition is any changes in the Barometric
pressure. When we experience stormy weather here in Florida, I end up so
ill and in such pain that I am flat on my back for the
duration. So, that makes me think that temperature changes of any kind can
seriously affect those of us who suffer with Fibromyalgia."
21. "My son developed pneumonia
from sleeping near a "water cooler." They're like an air conditioner, but
operate by having water continually flow over the coils and then a fan blows
that cooled air into the room. We lived in a dry part of TX at the
time. I've found that the old wives tales usually have some
"standing" in them ("don't go out in cold weather with your hair
wet). The problem with Fibromites is that we've a lowered immune
system which allows airborne viruses, etc., to take hold much more easily than a
"normal" person. These viruses also thrive in damp areas,
situations. With my hypothalamus out of whack due to the Fibro, I find I
can't tolerate changes in temperature. I also tend to run a lower body
temperature and am told this is also usual for my condition. Therefore, my
body doesn't generate the "heat" needed to destroy incoming contaminants.
In essence, those with Fibromyalgia are walking targets!"
22. "I find rapid cooling in the
weather can chill me and that can make me sick and then I flew on a
plane recently and really got sick despite taking vitamin c and using hand
sanitizer."
23. "I get sinus, sore throat attacks that come on
suddenly but I've blamed them on an allergy to something.
I can be fine one minute and then all of a sudden there it is. For you, I
wonder if it could be the mold spores coming out when you are near the
dampness....could have been some in the dress, etc. As
for the ice bags....I agree with your chiro on that one. Sorry, but I've
been helped tremendously from ice on the back. More so than heat although
the heat feels great. Maybe it's just the wetness and dampness in general
for you. I know the cold of Michigan winters really bother me......it's so
damp and the wind chills to the bone."
24. "I've always been told that being in cold
weather can't make you sick. I don't know about the dampness.
Doesn't seem like it should. And having a damp dress on just a few minutes
just doesn't make sense. When you get out of the shower and put a towel
around you for a few minutes to answer the phone, or something, one doesn't get
sick. But then again with fibro, nothing makes sense
anyway. I'm more apt to think you picked up a virus when out
shopping for that dress. Whenever I go shopping, or anywhere in public, I
wash my hands really good as soon as I walk in the house. My mom has
been telling me that for yrs, but just started doing that. Maybe we need
to keep wipes in our cars and do it when we get to the car and do our steering
wheels. I just thought of that, can you imagine what's on the steering
wheel? Makes you wonder though if we're supposed to be trying to avoid
everything, won't that weaken us even more?"
25. "Just a thought to let you
know, I have a sore throat and coughing and
sweating and feeling terrible, I felt it came on after the air
conditioner was on too cold, I suffer terrible when the weather changes from hot
to cold wet to windy, humid just weather in general seems to affect me, my body
cannot handle it, I am not sure about damp but going on the rest of it I would
say that your body is like mine it just cannot handle different temperatures
just another problem when you suffer from Fibromyalgia, good luck and I know
exactly how you feel."
26. "This is ridiculous on it's face, not to mention
shown in well controlled
studies to be absolutely untrue. FMS is an
illness in the brain. When it
"thinks" there is a threat, it acts on it like
it would act on a real
virus. That is why they changed CFS to CFIDS. The
immune system in
dysfunctional. It attacks things that are not a danger to
us, but
doesn't fight infection well. It turns on the immune response, and
sometimes it just won't turn off for days or years. This happens most
when one is worn out or overdoing; and in the winter when the heat
we
use in our homes dries out our mucus membranes and they are less
effective at keeping viruses or bacteria to penetrate. (that is their
job)
In my business, and among friends not ready to accept a diagnosis of a
syndrome with no known cure, I have heard people repeatedly say," I feel
like I'm coming down with something" they feel like that for a few days,
or feel mildly ill for several weeks or even months, but never actually
get the flue or a cold, etc. When I was in graduate school (at a medical
center), I was overworked due to the studying, working for the school,
and my internship. Then I found out my father-in another State-was
dying of lung cancer. Following finals, I came down with "strep throat".
This triggered an immune response that lasted for 2+ years. Same
symptoms as the writer, and 20 years later I still have health problems.
As long as I take care of myself well, don't overdo anything, have a
great wellness program, and keep toxic people out of my life, I do fine.
Get out of balance, and I get those symptoms again. It is NOT the
virus
I got 20 years ago. It is a strange combination of factors that lead
to
the study of Psychoneuroimmunology. That was what I
studied in grad
school, and there is an association of people that have
diseases or
syndromes that fall in this category. Try googling it. If you
can't find
it, email me and I'll point you in the right direction. The
bottom line?
Just because 2 things happen in close temporal proximity does
NOT mean
one caused the other. The best way to unlock these mysteries is to
keep a journal of symptoms,
actions, food intake, emotional state or stress,
for several months and
then show it to a doctor in the field. Then you can
find out what is
really going on and possibly prevent it. I have FMS. I feel
awful when I
am cold or damp. Aways have. The answer to "why"?, lies within.
Not from
a lifelong virus."
27. "Although getting
chilled can lower your resistance to certain viral infections, the virus would
have to be in your system already. Most viruses such as a cold or flu virus have
an incubation time of between three days and a week. If you have not got a virus
in your body, the infection will not ensue from being
chilled. If the infection is
bacterial, the chilling can cause a relapse because it creates a better
environment in your body to replicate. Germs replicate very quickly, so lowering
your body temperature can give them a foothold. In
both cases, the germs have to be present in your body
already. Also, I’d give Wikipedia a careful
look askance… Wikipedia can be edited by anyone at any time. It’s a website
where people all over contribute their knowledge. Whereas this is very
interesting, it is also not necessarily an entirely reliable source for
important information. Try health
sites like mayo clinic and such for more reliable
information."
28. "In spite of what the "experts" claim that cold,
damp air does not cause a cold or sore throat, I know my body and
when exposed to these conditions I get a cold, sore throat, and sinus
congestion. Just this past week our windows were open all night (my
husband is always hot, and I am always cold!!!) and a breeze blew over my
head, and I came down with a very bad sinus infection. I can not even tolerate
sitting near a fan for fear of getting sick. My mother-in-law also has this
problem. No one seems to believe us when we tell them. Our medical
"experts" may never agree with this, but I suspect you will have many
people confirming what we know to be true."
29. "I would recommend you get NAET treatments for dampness
and humidity. I am feeling better. They should have them in
vials and you can always hold a damp cloth when they do the NAET
treatment."
30. "Colds, etc., are brought on by viruses, bugs, and can't
be brought on by getting chilled alone. I used to take a shower
and wash my hair, towel dry it and go to work the winter. It's a
coincidence if you get sick after trying on a wet dress. When I was a
little girl, I came down with the Measles the morning after I was doing
somersaults in my back yard. I thought that somersaults caused Measles and
would not do them for many years after that."
31. "Viruses cause colds ,sore throats etc...
you dont get
sick from getting wet..but why more in the winter? because when the
doors and windows are closed tight the "germs" are trapped indoors and are are
more easily passed from one person to another.. The best germ fighter is, on a
cold winter day..turn down the heat and open the windows and let the cold air
blow through your house( even if the neighbors do think you are crazy...)
I do think however if your resistance is low, you might make yourself more
susceptible by getting run down, no sleep chilled and damp...then if you have
been exposed to a sore throat virus you probably will be more likely to
get it.. but the virus MUST be present to start! This article is
very informative:
http://www.healthcaresouth.com/pages/askthedoctor/commoncold.html."
32. "Mold is always worse in damp or humid climates. I think
the mold sort of reactivates. Next time you are in a moldy place, take
note of how you feel. When I stay at a hotel, I usually get a sore throat
and my guess is that it's probably pretty moldy. I went to visit my cousin
who was staying at a hotel near Disneyland in California where I live.
There was a huge outdoor pool area and there was indoor/outdoor carpeting in
front of the rooms and near the pool. I was there a few minutes and could
feel my throat sore and ears plugged and developing a headache. So
what we think is a cold might just be our immune system over reacting to the
mold - similar to an allergy or maybe the mold reactivating in us. Maybe
the dress you got at the thrift store was already old and musty and when you wet
it became worse. I do believe that our body doesn't regulate
temperature etc. but I feel that the root cause is some infection that
affects the central nervous system - like a fungal or bacterial
infection. But that's just a guess. I've been sensitive to mold for a
while and used to get allergy shots for it. I recently got tested
and didn't test positive for mold sensitivity but why is it that when I'm around
musty/moldy places I feel terrible?"
33. "As a nurse we were versed on this all the time,
and every reasearch says no that a chill will not bring on a cold or virus .
However they also say that if you have been ill, or your resistance
is low then a chill can make it worse and you would be susceptible to a
cold or virus. I have looked into this myself I am seem to get ill when I go in
unfamiliar places, touch things that others have touched or worn, eat where
there is a large group of people . I hate the Doctor's office because when
I go there I nearly all the time get sick a few days after. Just two
weeks ago my daughter in law I went to a Goodwill Thrift Shop
and were looking at jeans, jackets and other items for the girls for play .
I got awful sick in about 24 hours. I try and stay away from
stores, shops, events, even church when there is an outbreak of colds and
flu going around. True, I think we are more able to catch those things
than normal people, but today I was out in the icy wind finding my trash cans
that blew away, and putting my downspout up that blew off and I feel fine .Even
in the summer going out to eat or a picnic worries me .I think its objects that
touch us and have been on other people, or being around places and people that
carry it , that does not mean they get ill , but can pass it on to people like
us .As soon as school starts and the grand kids come around I get sick right
away even if they don't have anything. I keep my house sparkle clean
and use lots of bleach, and wash, wash my hands, always cleaning door knobs and
counters. I guess that's something we will never know but I do think its
things other people touched, germs in the air and people that carry it to
us. I started writing down where I was and what I was doing when I go
places then see what happens!"
34. "I have ALWAYS, ALWAYS fallen ill with respiratory
illness when I get a
chill, damp chill, or even FEEL COLD for a few minutes
- if I am lightly
dressed and there is a cool wind. All I
have to do is start shivering
for a few minutes and the next day, I will be
ill. I have learnt NEVER
to go out without a sweater or jacket because I
have learnt that if I
get a chill, I get sick - swollen glands,
cough, sore throat, fever.
Whereas others don't, in the same
circumstances...
I have however been taking a combination of vitamins that
they sell in
my country (South Africa) called Vita-Thion, since April this
year when
I could not shake off a lingering cough and sinus infection - and
this
has kept me safe from flu and gives me enough energy to get through the
day. It contains:
Ascorbic Acid 500mg
Glutathion 0.5mg
Vitamin B1
2.0mg
Sodium Adenosin Triphosphate 0.5mg
Calcium Inositol Hexaphosphate
100mg
(excipients).
If I do not take it I have zero energy and can
only lie on my bed all
day and mourn my lost life."
35. "I have friends in medical fields that would
tell you that it is impossible to catch a cold from a chill unless you had a
virus just waiting to happen. It could be that there are those that really
never get rid of the virus so they do have one just waiting to pop
out. Now my Mother's diagnosis would be completely
different. If your head or feet got wet or you sit in a draft or
in front of or under a fan too long you're going to get a cold.
As hard as I've tried in my sixty plus years I've never found my Mother to be
wrong. As a side note, I went to my Lyme Disease doctor a couple of
days ago and he thinks that 60% of those with Fibromyalgia really have Lyme
Disease. He says that research is leaning that way. Either they have
not been tested or the doctor who read the test didn't read it correctly.
He sends his lab for testing to one lab in New Jersey. This lab only does
test for lyme disease. Just food for thought."
36. "I have also heard that colds are not
CAUSED by getting cold or damp but because of germs and poor resistance to them.
However, if I go out in the cold damp weather I immediately have an
increase in my fibro symptoms--one of which is a sore throat. I went
camping once and got so misreable with fibro symptoms I had to leave and come
home. It was really damp in the tent. I try to avoid getting cold or damp
because I feel better if I can stay dry and warm."
37. "I was feeling okay sinus and no colds then got
out in the damp to put a few Christmas things out in the yard. Got on the
damp ground for a short time. It's been rainy and
just usual Tennessee weather for December here. Now I have a cold and
sinus real bad. So I think for us Fibro people everything affects us
different. I used to never get sick with much. Now my life
is so different."
38. " I HAVE HAD A COLD LIKE VIRUS OR HALF GERM/HALF
VIRUS FOR EVER I THINK. I LIVE IN THE SALT LAKE CITY VALLEY
WHICH IS MOSTLY DRY - BUT I KNOW WHEN IT IS MOIST OUT - THE WIND ETC.
SEEMS TO CUT THROUGH ME WORSE. BUT I DON'T THINK IT HAS MADE A BIG
DIFFERENCE IN GETTING A COLD OR VIRUS. I WONDER IF OTHERS
HAVE A 1/2 OR 1 DEGREE LOWER "NORMAL TEMPERATURE" THAN THE NORMAL
98.6. I ALWAYS RUN LOWER THAN NORMAL. MY BASIC THOUGHT
ABOUT WHAT YOU WROTE IS I THINK MAYBE WE HAVE THIS VIRUS/GERM GOING
ALL THE TIME AND A LITTLE EXTRA PROBLEM JUST BRINGS IT OUT- THEN OUR SYSTEM HAS
TO FIGHT HARDER. I DON'T THINK IT EVER LEAVES
ALL THE WAY. "
Yes, my temperature often runs a
degree below normal. When I get a mild fever of 99.1 I feel ill.
Maybe that's like having a 100.6 temperature for a normal
person?
39. "First about the cold: I can't give you the
reference but there was a peer review reference study about people who
put their feet in cold water. this study demonstrated increased
susceptibility to illness like colds from being chilled. (even though in the
past this has been dismissed as wives' tale, research now supports).
Secondly, I would guess with the thrift store item it wasn't the chilled part
but the mold. Honey, as someone with cfs/fms I would
never buy anything at a thrift store. Not only are you dealing with
storage issues, mold/mildew, but also "who knows what" kind of fabric
softener/detergent chemicals are there. These things all make me horribly
sick. Also as a warning, you may want to share with your readers; I just got
very sick two weekends in a row: First weekend, my husband got a
new big screen TV which offgassed horrible
chemicals and gave me the worst headache that lasted two days. You
could smell it all over the house. Second weekend, my mother in law
sprayed air freshener. I probably don't need to expound on that
one. But warn people on your site about buying new appliances because heated
plastic not only has cancer causing chemicals like phalates which can harm
"Normal' people over time, they can make "us" very sick
immediately."